Pilgrim: A Medieval Horror by Mitchell Luthi is a thought-provoking, fantasy-laced medieval Odyssey. It is breathtaking, panoramic, violent and epic in scope, myths, creatures and locations. The prose is flowery and haunting, disturbing and poetic. The book is also profoundly spiritual at times but never preachy or overly sentimental as it sometimes pits the characters’ deeply held religious beliefs at odds with one another.
Dietmar of Zwingenborg, a Christian, and Razin al-Did Ibram al-Ramla, a Muslim, are the two central characters in a book with several unique and distinct characters. With a ragtag ensemble, they set out, on secret church business, to illegally transport a holy relic, the rotting fetid arm of Saint Eleza Ephium from the Outremer to Naples, Italy.
The story is set in the time of King Amalric, whose son, Baldwin, is a leper.
Dietmar lost his wife and son, and because his son wasn’t yet baptized, fears the boy will suffer eternal torment. If he completes this odd task, the pope may be able to save him. The thought of his son weighs heavily on Dietmar throughout the tale.
A great desert storm overtakes the travelers and when it clears, nothing is as it was before. They can’t identify the landscape or the night stars.
The party encounters poisoned water wells and unimaginable creatures along the way.
Razin, having studied, begins to relate the things they are encountering to Muslim stories, which are rooted in Christian stories as well. The characters start to see many of these tales they are living through from the perspective of their beliefs, and they begin to feel cursed, in a manner not unlike Dante’s Inferno.
Dietmar used the rotting hand of Saint Ephium to help them escape one place and now he’s hearing a voice in his head. The voice only gets louder with each passing day. He tries to keep this reality from everyone else, but it is difficult.
The other characters are also suffering their own personal traumas, physical, spiritual and psychological.
Razin’s encounter with a seductive spirit scars him with guilt while Adelman begins speaking with the donkeys.
Pilgrim is not an action-packed adventure but there is plenty of action when action is called for. And when the action happens, it is violent, bloody and horrific as can be expected from a horror story involving strange mythical creatures with strange mythical abilities.
I didn’t find any of the characters to be flat or unoriginal. They all have strong identifiable traits and histories, and their personalities tend to mold their decision making.
The whole story is absolutely fascinating. I think it’s a wonderful book and the author is a talented writer.
It can be a bit long winded and political at points, especially in the beginning before the journey starts. After that, it coasts along at a much better rate with only a few deviations. It is a weighty work after all. There is a lot of depth and history involved. All the spiritual messaging, psychology and horror elements come together masterfully. Five stars.

Allen M Werner is the author of THE CRYSTAL CRUX SERIES and the SHADES OF MYTH series.

The Crystal Crux Series

I’d like your feedback

Trending